Thursday, June 7, 2012

The Blue Bunny Effect



Have you ever thought about what it takes to produce your everyday clothing? Have you ever thought about the pain and suffering that might be caused from buying clothing from your favorite store? Neither have I. In my mind when I think of clothing being manufactured, I think of the Devil Wears Prada, the designing aspect of clothing production, but my mind rarely wanders to where the materials actually come from. Most people forget that leather is made from cows, pigs, and even kangaroos. A snakeskin boot or a crocodile handbag was made from an actual reptile. Okay, maybe not too shocking, but from my research on the subject of clothing production and animal welfare I have found it is all too common that it isn’t animal welfare it is exactly the opposite, it’s animal cruelty. To get a better idea of the magnitude of this is in the definition of cruelty from Cruelty’s rewards: The gratifications of perpetrators and spectators by Andrew Rowan states “cruelty (from the Latin crudelem, “morally rough”) is the deliberate infliction of physical or psychological pain on a living creature.”


During my research, I viewed different sites ranging from the PETA and ASPCA foundations to YouTube and Blogger. Here is what I found on each and every site, abuse. The problem is for me, and many others out there we conclude that when animals are skinned they are already dead. However, this is far from the truth. On every site I viewed I found evidence of this and other abuses, and every time it took only seconds for my stomach to turn and for me to avert my eyes and stop the unimaginable video. The fact that it took me less than 30 minutes to find so easily countless videos of abuse makes my heart break. To me, cruelty of animals is all too real and evident in our “daily society”.

Well, now that my eyes are opened, and I hope yours are too, we can talk about how to avoid situations such as these. In the reading of Fashioning Sustainability (Forum for the Future), I have already solved one of the issues of ensuring animal welfare in my blog, “raising awareness”. In this portion of the forum it is discussed that 130,000 animals are killed every day just for their fur coats. 130,000 animals? That means that almost three times the population of Stillwater, OK could be clothed with fur coats in just one day. To me it seems quite ridiculous; to waste so many animals lives for just one portion of their bodies. Yes, not all, but some products are produced from animals slaughtered for only one purpose. These animals are not slaughtered for their meat, hooves, skin, fur, and horns, but slaughtered for only one part of the whole animal. This is where it becomes evident to me that I no longer want clothes that are produced from animals that are not cruelty free products. What is a cruelty free product you ask? It is essentially a product that is not created from an animal on an “endangered species list, but is a by-product of the meat industry, and has a ‘no-fur policy”. If you would like a list of companies or products that follow this policy on the products they produce you can search the PETA website or click this web address: http://www.peta.org/living/beauty-and-personal-care/companies/default.aspx.


 Another problem I discovered in the readings of Shifting the New Dominant Social Paradigm in the Apparel Industry: Acknowledging the Pink Elephant by Cosette Armstrong and Melody LeHew and in my own research is the problem of the so-called “pink elephant (consumerism).” In short, consumers without knowledge of what is put into the products they purchase will continue to go on choosing the “cheaper option” of products instead of choosing the cruelty free product which is more sustainable and ethical than the other. What needs to happen next is a paradigm shift, the “old procedures and rules need to be replaced as a new paradigm makes them flawed” (Armstrong). The new paradigm needs to be pro cruelty free products! As consumers gain awareness and knowledge of this subject, cruelty free products will be quite possibly be in higher demand. You might ask, “how can just one person help when so many producers do not provide cruelty free products?” The answer is that you are not alone, after further research one can assume consumers are the driving force behind sustainability in clothing, and care about the materials used in the products they purchase. This means that if given a choice between a cruelty free product and a non-cruelty free product the consumer will choose to purchase the cruelty free product despite a possible increase in price. Understandably, consumers want more human and environmentally friendly products. Quite possibly, the more people that incorporate this idea will help to drive clothing markets to make safer and more humane choices simply because of the consumers needs! Another question you might ask,  “how do I find such items? What do I look for when purchasing cruelty-free products?” Regrettably the government does not mandate that products be labeled as such. Therefore, you as a consumer must do your research before you shop alleviating this problem. One last alternative is to look for the bunny. This is a label that has been deemed for the cruelty-free products.

The idea of creating a sustainable product has the preface that it needs to “meet the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” as The Designer’s Atlas of Sustainability by Anne Thorpe states. Therefore, the next time you go shopping for a new pair of shoes, a belt, or countless other options check if you can find out about the product first before purchasing. Is it a cruelty free product? Does it help on the quest of sustainability? Is it eco friendly? If it is, then you are helping the present and future generations carry on the sustainable endeavor and giving us the consumer a better and more humane choice.

10 comments:

  1. Hi, Haley;
    You have done a really nice job developing your blog this week. I really appreciate that you took an issue that you were interested in and pursued some research about it. Thank you for sharing what "cruelty free" means exactly. You have used the course readings nicely, combining them with your own research. As you were doing your research, did you find some apparel or home products being made from this "cruelty free" materials? Just curious. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dr. Armstrong,

      Thank you so much for your support! As I stated in my blog, because of the government it is not required to state whether or not clothing is cruelty free. However, the easiest way I found clothing that were cruelty free was by searching through some vegan clothing sites. Most of this clothing is either made from synthetic materials or natural materials instead of animals. I also gave a link from the PETA site, but that mainly contains home products rather than clothing. I just stumbled upon a site that is sponsored by ebay called worldofgood.com which states it is "ethically sourced Fair Trade and eco-friendly clothing." Other than that, the best way of identifying is looking for the blue bunny or researching before you buy. I wish there was a better or easier way of doing so, but until the government instills this in companies personal research is almost the only way.

      Delete
    2. Great, thanks for sharing! I have noticed some brands kind of taking advantage of this "vegan" tag. I was shopping in Boulder one time and found a shoe I really liked. The sales person said, "Oh, that's from our new 'vegan' line." I was immediately impressed. When she returned with a pair for me to try on, I asked her what they were made of, and she said, "Canvas." So, it was not transparent to me what made these different from a pair of Converse'. Unless, they are not using glue that is made with animal parts. Boy, we have a long way to go when it comes to labeling!

      Delete
    3. Your welcome! Yes, we do have a tremendously long way to go before people are able to know exactly what they are buying in stores! I am sure I would have been convinced to buy the shoes simply because of the "vegan" label, and I'm not totally sure I would have asked her what they were made of. I'm glad you did have interest in what you were buying. I think so many people, like me, end up buying things they think are beneficial in helping the environment, but get fooled by information just like this! But, hopefully the more people find out about these factors the better support there will be in making a change!

      Delete
  2. Haley,
    I really like that you took a completely different standpoint on the topic and focused on animal cruelty. I think that if people really understood what was happening behind the scenes, they would be a lot less likely to still purchase that piece. I agree with you that people tend to choose the cheapest product without really knowing much behind it, I mean I'm even guilty! What do you think would happen with a labeling system? The only thing about that is I think I would be really odd to pick up a shirt and the label reads "animal cruelty was present during the making of this item." Maybe companies could just start incorporating "cruelty-free" on their labels and people would start to look for that on the label and be more aware of what they are purchasing! I remember when I was reading the article by Forum of the Future I was I really shocked as well at the statistics on the animal cruelty and I'm glad that you chose to focus on that for your blog!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, before doing this research I was guilty of assuming the clothing I bought was eco-friendly or cruelty-free. Boy, was I wrong! I think a labeling system would be the best way to go about providing information to consumers. The blue bunny is a label put on some clothing, but it is still not very well known. It would be really odd to find a shirt that reads "animal cruelty was present during the making of this item." I would probably leave the store and not purchase their clothing anymore. This is probably why the government doesn't require this. The affect of this on companies would be devastating to their sales. However, I feel the same way about food, and most grocery stores have got on board with organic food while still selling non organic food and are doing just fine! Hopefully with time this will change for the clothing industry as well.

      Delete
  3. Haley,
    I loved how you took too separate issues and combined them with the same actions taken by consumers and designers. While most of us have solely concentrated on sustainability and just that you have taken another point of view which made it interesting for me to read and connect to what you have to say! I agree that animal cruelty should be stopped and it breaks my heart to rally know what goes on in our industries involving leather and such materials. As it is known that awareness of sustainability issues and animal cruelty issues need to be stronger, Do you thing that if the too issues and corporations united together to raise awareness it could make a better impact to make a change in the paradigm?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your comments, I hoped that focusing on one point of view rather than the whole issue I could draw more interest! Of, course I believe if corporations united together and raised awareness on the subject it would make a huge impact. Just think of the Dove commercial and how it raised awareness on the image of models and normal women. It has definitely changed my idea of what women should really look like. If corporations raised the awareness themselves just as Dove did, it would in my opinion transform societies idea of cruelty free clothing completely! This in turn would change to paradigm because consumers would see the old paradigm as flawed.

      Delete
  4. Hi Hayley! I'm so glad we are blog buddies!! I loved reading your blog just now, what a very interesting approach. You did a wonderful job of researching and I can tell you are very passionate about preventing animal cruelty. I think that is a topic that sometimes gets over looked when it comes to fashion trends. I feel like people will do whatever it takes to be a part of the trend, thereforei appreciate you taking a stand on what you believe. But hopefully raising the awareness of animal cruelty will help to prevent the ongoing pink elephant concerning that matter. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks Hannah!

    I am glad we are blog buddies as well! Thank you for your support, and I agree the topic is very much overlooked. That is why I think so many people are unknowledgeable about the subject, including me before I researched about it. Yes, I hope as more people become aware the better it will be for society. Awareness really is key!

    ReplyDelete